I broke down.  I'm embarrassed to say  it, but I gave in and signed up for digital TV from 
Comcast (aka "the man").  I think I did it because I wanted the Hallmark channel back, or maybe I did it because I saw an ad for a 
Tivo HD ($249 at 
Frys) which I decided I couldn't live without (it's replacing my 
SnapStream BeyondTV  and 
Hauppauge MediaMVP)
It doesn't matter why, but I did it.  After many calls to Comcast, I was happy that I could get a decent plan that had the things I wanted (basic digital cable, with local channels in HD), and, most important, no cable box
The appointment was set for between noon and 4pm on Tuesday; Comcast even called to make sure someone would be home.  they called three times in fact.  They called on Saturday.  Then they called at 11:30am on Tuesday and left a message.  I called them back and confirmed.  They called again at 1pm.  Sheesh, you people worry too much.
CableBoy showed up at 2:30pm and we discussed his mission - install an M- CableCard™ in the Tivo, and an S- CableCard™ in my TV.  Seemed straightforward to me, and to the person I scheduled the appointment with who was fluent in CableCard™-speak.  But not so with CableBoy.
He had never seen a TivoHD, so he didn't believe that it could operate both digital tuners with a single M- CableCard™.  I showed him the Tivo documentation.  Nope, not a believer.  I told him the "M" meant multi-stream.  Nothing still.  So he called his colleague - characterized as the Tivo HD "Subject Matter Expert."  The SME confirmed what I said, but pointed out that I couldn't get OnDemand nor Pay-Per-View (BFD).
Alas, CableBoy only had S-cards with him (he refered to them as "the green ones"), no M-cards ("the pink ones").  SME pointed out that there were two slots in my Tivo, so two S-cards would work fine.  Yes, they would, but, as I pointed out, I'd then be paying for a third card; at $1.79/month, it adds up, so CableBoy got a timeout and sat in his truck until a colleague with "the pink ones" arrived.
Installation started with CableBoy testing the cable that went from my surge protector to the TV/Tivo (through a splitter).  He decided, I guess, that he didn't like what he saw, because he installed his own splitter, bypassing my surge protector completely.
The rest of the install was fine, apart from a mistyped ID somewhere that initially prevented the M-card from pairing.  CableBoy tested the encrypted channels on the Tivo, they worked fine.  I asked him to test the ones on the TV, he said "they won't work."  Why, I asked (like a two year old?).  He said "because the TV needs a cable box for that."  Err, isn't that why we put a CableCard™ in there?  He gave in and tuned the TV to channel 702, and magically it worked.
As he was packing up to leave, I asked him about the splitter he had installed.  He said it was necessary.  I pointed out that it now bypassed 
my surge protector.  He said that wasn't a problem, the cable was grounded outside (didn't inspire confidence).  I asked what was wrong with my surge protector.  He said "you can't have anything between the cable and our device (the CableCard™).
I was going to point out that a mere 8 feet below him, in the white box on the garage wall was a big freaking amplifier that was effectively sitting between "the cable" and his device, but thought that would make him cry, so I let him off easy - Merry Christmas CableBoy.
Labels: beyondtv, cablecard, comcast, hauppauge, snapstream, tivo